COLD COPY (Tribeca 2023) – Review by Valerie Kalfrin

0 Flares 0 Flares ×

Journalism movies tend to swing between two extremes: those with the inside feel of the profession, such as 2015’s Spotlight, and those that indulge the most bottom-feeding sensationalistic instincts, a la 2014’s Nightcrawler.

As someone who was a crime reporter for ten years, I’m partial to the former, but I can be enthralled by a knotty Network story, too. Cold Copy, which debuted at the 2023 Tribeca Film Festival, aims to say something profound about ambition and competition in the profession. The trouble is, it’s a message we’ve heard before—and done better.

Making her feature debut, writer-director Roxine Helberg focuses Cold Copy on the relationship between an eager postgraduate journalism student and the seasoned TV reporter she’s determined to impress.

Yet Mia (Bel Powley, The Morning Show) shows so few ethics at the outset, we’re not surprised by the lines she oversteps later. She’s also a cipher, with little motivation about why she’s so hungry to succeed in a profession so cutthroat, one character says workers fight over the bagels in the breakroom.

The film opens as Mia rehearses a speech about speaking truth to power, complete with an expletive for emphasis, to audition for a slot in an investigative seminar taught by TV veteran Diane Heger (Tracee Ellis Ross, Black-ish).

Ross plays Diane with the bearing of a woman who didn’t have easy breaks and is determined to make her students work for theirs. She challenges the inscrutable Mia to reveal something galvanizing.

“You’re so focused on trying to look the part, you’re not actually playing it,” Diane says, in one of the script’s better lines.

Mia nevertheless lands a slot in the seminar, joining her roommate, Kim (Nesta Cooper, See), in one of the plot’s several coincidences. Another is how Mia runs across a story to pitch, encountering Igor (Jacob Tremblay, My Father’s Dragon), the teenage son of a children’s book author who died a few years prior from a reported accidental overdose.

Although Diane finds some of Mia’s footage with Igor artistic, she says there’s no story there, spurring Mia to dig deeper. In the meantime, if Mia has to exploit this kid or sabotage someone else’s piece to enter Diane’s good graces, well … that’s not really an issue, since Mia hasn’t shown a conscience all along.

By giving Mia no growth, Cold Copy comes across as flat and predictable, with plodding pacing and a less-than-involving denouement.

That’s a shame, because there’s a meaty journalism story in the state of the profession these days. Just this month, The Atlantic covered “the meltdown at CNN” after the Trump town hall, and the publisher of The New York Times spoke to The New Yorker about axed jobs and the vacuum of accountability.

There are absolutely uncovered stories out there or ones covered the wrong way. Yet instead of creating a believable dilemma for a dynamic protagonist, Cold Copy serves up yesterday’s news.

0 Flares Twitter 0 Facebook 0 0 Flares ×

Valerie Kalfrin

Valerie Kalfrin is an award-winning crime journalist turned freelance film writer whose work appears at RogerEbert.com, In Their Own League, Script, The Hollywood Reporter, and other outlets. Also a screenwriter and script consultant, she’s passionate about challenging stereotypes about gender and disability. Let’s tell better stories and tell stories better.