ARGYLLE – Review by Valerie Kalfrin
The loopy spy caper Argylle has more plot twists and jackknifes than the Fast & Furious franchise. Tug on any thread, and you’ll get a hole.
Yet with director Matthew Vaughn, best known for Kick-Ass and the Kingsman films, one expects foolishness. This isn’t Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy—or even The Spy Who Loved Me.
Argylle is preposterous and messy, but I’ve seen worse, and without the good cheer of Bryce Dallas Howard and Sam Rockwell. It’s pitched at a heightened reality with cartoonish stunts, over-the-top action, zany dance choreography, and disco music. I doubt I’ll see another sequence this year with someone on jerry-rigged knife-blade ice skates slaying enemies in a sit-spin, or people twirling in a gunfight among smoke canisters that bloom into technicolor hearts.
The cockamamie setup sees Howard (Jurassic World Dominion) as Elly Conway, a wildly successful author drawn into some real life-or-death stuff. It’s like Romancing the Stone (or any of its 1980s imitators), except instead of romance, Elly writes espionage novels about secret agent Argylle (Henry Cavill, The Witcher, sporting a green velvet suit and a flat-top haircut) on the trail of a rogue spy agency.
On the cusp of her latest novel’s release, a real rogue agency wants to kill or capture Elly because her books mirror their hunt for a flash drive containing the goods to expose their evildoings. We never learn what those are, and this agency hasn’t been able to lay its hands on this device in five years, so they don’t exactly inspire fear. Bryan Cranston (Asteroid City) tries, scowling and barking at underlings clacking on keyboards when they’re not pursuing Elly.
Enter Sam Rockwell (See How They Run) as Aiden, a rogue operative from said agency, who rides to Elly’s rescue to reach the widget first. He’s in league with Samuel L. Jackson (The Marvels) as an ex-CIA guy. Jackson has a hideout at a French winery where he spends part of the movie watching basketball, like a low- key Nick Fury.
Rockwell’s shaggy-dog screwball demeanor and his penchant for dancing inspire much of the comedy, literally butting up against Elly’s idea of a suave superspy. In an early fight scene, editors Tom Harrison-Read and Lee Smith cut between Rockwell kicking butt (and getting his handed to him) while Elly’s brain toggles between this rough-and-tumble fellow and Cavill, winking, dodging, and decking.
Aiden has his own particular set of skills, though. He leaps up through wooden floorboards and takes out operatives better than Trinity in The Matrix, then demonstrates how to smash a skull while doing a little soft shoe.
Elly grated on me at first. She has an overbearing mother (Catherine O’Hara, Pain Hustlers) nagging her to find a date, wears pajamas while working, talks to and snuggles her cat, and runs and squeals once the trouble starts. Howard has a natural warmth and an endearing charm that helps smooth over this, but I thought the accomplished director (Dads, The Mandalorian) deserved better. Happily, Elly evolves, but couldn’t screenwriter Jason Fuchs (I Still See You) avoid such creaky sexist stereotypes?
Knowing Argylle’s biggest twist, the film could’ve been a lot wackier, especially in the relationships between Cavill and the underused John Cena and Ariana De Bose as the fictional spy’s backup. That said, it’s fun enough if you let the lunacy roll.
