ODDITY – Review by Nadine Whitney

0 Flares 0 Flares ×

Damien McCarthy’s Oddity is a gripping supernatural story which combines a particular real-world paranoia. What if science also had absolute control over one’s liberty?

Dani Timmis (Caroline Bracken) is renovating a property she and her psychiatrist husband Doctor Ted Timmis (Gwilym Lee) have purchased in West Cork. It’s a sprawling remote place where cell service is spotty at best. Ted works nights at a hospital mostly for those deemed criminally insane. It’s antiquated and overlooked, the kind of place Health Service executives aren’t paying attention to.

Dani’s solitude at the property is interrupted by a knock on the door. Glass-eyed Olin Boone (Tadhg Murphy) tells her she must leave immediately as someone has snuck into the house and means her harm. Dani replies that her husband will be home shortly. “The doctor works nights,” Boone rejoins. It’s then that Dani clicks that he was one of Ted’s patients. He’s insistent that she’s in danger and begs her to call the police or let him in. Dani’s hand wavers over the doorknob.

Almost a year later an horrific murder occurs at the hospital partially witnessed by another patient who has a fascination with drawing – one of his subjects is Boone, another an anthrophage in a muzzle. The victim is Olin Boone.

Dani’s death anniversary is coming up. Ted visits her twin sister, Darcy (also played by Bracken) in her antique store ‘Odello’s Oddities.’ Darcy is blind and uses a glass eye to see the future, but she doesn’t know Ted is her customer. She warns him that all the items in the shop are cursed and only payment will make them safe. Ted laughs at people’s gullibility. He’s long thought Darcy and her deceased mother to be victims and perpetrators of supernatural fraud. Darcy suggests that they should get together to remember Dani at the house. He demurs telling her he would have to organise it with his girlfriend Yana. The fact he has a live-in girlfriend is a surprise to Darcy, but then again, they haven’t been in consistent contact since Dani’s death.

Darcy takes the eye to her apartment and reads it. What she sees is a masked figure – the man convicted for Dani’s murder was innocent. Darcy decides that it is time she visited Ted and Yana (Caroline Melton) and brings with her a particular gift, a human sized wooden mannequin given to her mother by a witch. It ignites disgust in Yana and bemusement in Ted. Darcy’s presence rankles the couple. Darcy pretends to have misunderstood that she wasn’t invited to the now decorated home and despite her hosts telling her they both have to leave – Yana for her flat in the city, and Ted to work in the hospital, it is Darcy’s intention to stay until she gets what she wants.

Shadows move across the house; shadows Darcy cannot see but feels. Yana who tried to square off against Darcy with perceived superiority is out classed by her intelligence and her disregard for niceties. Sitting across from Yana is not only Darcy but the mannequin – a golem set with her will. Yana is equally discomforted by the wooden poupée with a face frozen somewhere between terror and attack as she is by the woman whose face rarely changes at all. When she calls Ted, he says that surely she can handle a blind woman for one night. If all that Yana was dealing with comprised of a strange interrogative woman perhaps she could handle it – but flickers that she had seen in the house have awoken.

McCarthy’s vision of the paternalism of medical science in conflict with the arcane arts which connected sisters and a mother is more than a clash of belief but an expression of how masculine pride and hubris others that it cannot confine. “We are connected!” Dani’s phone message to Darcy said. For Darcy the connection is never to be severed.

Oddity is ferociously intelligent. As the film progresses and plays its slow hand the audience realises that many of the answers were in clear view from the beginning. A psychiatric hospital where only one doctor, one orderly, and the patients are in focus. The orderly, Ivan (Steven Wall) who thrums with sadism. An antiques store filled with items with histories haunted and portentous. The mixture of supernatural horror with the failure of care in the medical community is rarely done in a contemporary setting.

McCarthy’s cat and mouse and animate wooden golem tale is redolent of gothic horror imagery, and within the gothic are conventions Oddity lovingly embraces. A ‘castle’ with hidden and dark recesses, connections that exist beyond death, entrapment.

As Oddity moves towards its conclusion it feels both unexpected and perfectly in tune with everything McCarthy plotted. McCarthy’s Caveat showed great promise with its atmosphere and ambition. Oddity sees McCarthy focus plotting to match atmosphere. Oddity is a new gothic horror classic marking the emergence of an undeniable talent.

0 Flares Twitter 0 Facebook 0 0 Flares ×

Nadine Whitney

Nadine Whitney is a seasoned film critic and scholar. Based in Melbourne, Australia, Nadine contributes regularly to FILMINK, The Curb, and Mr Movies Film Blog. She holds a degree in cinema theory and cultural studies. Her specialty is surrealism in cinema. She is as passionate about cats as she is about film. She is co-chair of the Australian Film Critics Association and a member of FIPRESCI.