IN THE SUMMERS – Review by Diane Carson
In the Summers burrows into two sisters’ reactions to a volatile father
First time feature film directors have a formidable challenge. Can they navigate demanding, numerous technical details and also deliver an innovative story with engaging performances? For American-Mexican writer/director Alessandra Lacorazza Samudio, factor in a semi-autobiographical drama, often a pitfall for any director, presented in succession by young and teenage actors at different times in the central characters’ lives.
What Lacorazza Samudio achieves, then, with In the Summers is nothing short of masterful filmmaking. The title signals summer break visits in Las Cruces, New Mexico, by two very different sisters with their estranged father Vincente. He’ll struggle to bond with the more confrontational, less traditional Violeta and subdued, sweeter Eva. The story follows them as children, teenagers, and then young adults, their connections developing, evolving, and maturing as Vincente conquers or succumbs to his demons.
Though clearly estranged and edgy around his daughters, Vincente loves, even dotes on them, and they initially welcome his attention. All of this is, atypically and refreshingly, conveyed implicitly, as are Vincente’s anger, alcohol, and drug problems. The multidimensional relationship they enact among themselves is alternately hesitant, exuberant, and awkward, while honest in every detail.
Consistent with her unique accomplishment, in opening screen titles writer/director Lacorazza Samudio states: In the Summers includes dialogue in both English and Spanish, presented without subtitles to authentically express the characters’ experiences. I made this choice to allow audiences to engage with emotions that transcend language.” She thereby directs attention to the minute nuances expressed by Vincente, Violeta, and Eva, as well as by supporting characters. Indeed, in four chapters, the film effectively. nonverbally communicates the sisters’ reactions. Ranging from dismay to disengagement, resentment to outright anger, Violeta and Eva eloquently respond to Vincente’s behavior toward them and others with sidelong glances, downcast eyes, averted gazes, and slumped shoulders.
Action is anchored in the house Vincente inherited from his mother, a Spanish home complete with an inviting pool, at least in the first chapter. The house itself becomes a strong character for, a museum of past experiences, it shelters boxes of cherished photos, altars, and mementos that tease interpretation. The local bar adds a public space where Vincente teaches his girls to play pool, though he can’t tolerate losing. Bar owner Carmen plays a major role, especially as an alternative role model for Violeta and a moderating influence.
Several incidents severely complicate family dynamics, some quite unexpected though always believable given the personalities and challenges of all three primary characters. Pain will alternate with love, success with failure, advances with setbacks. Even in the opening, brief introduction to Vincente as he waits to greet his girls at the airport, René Pérez Joglar’s performance skillfully, silently establishes a depth of conflicting emotions, announcing an actor and a director in full control of their communication. Similarly, cinematographer Alejandro Majia alternates darker, restrictive interior shots expressing entrapment with lovely, open New Mexico locations, where the film was filmed, including a trip to White Sands National Park.
In this, her semi-autobiographical feature film debut, Alessandra Lacorazza Samudio announces a remarkable talent to follow and root for. In the Summers won the 2024 Sundance Film Festival Grand Jury Prize in the Dramatic category as well as the U.S. Dramatic Award for Directing, Screenwriting, and Editing.
