THE OLD GUARD 2 – Review by Lynn Venhaus
A lackluster follow-up to the engaging action-packed original, The Old Guard 2 disappoints with a murky, morose narrative that fails to recapture any energy shown in the first superhero fantasy adventure.
Returning are the tight-knit gang of four ancient warriors who are contemporary mercenaries helping humanity, led by the protective shield of Andy, aka Andromache (Charlize Theron), her right-hand man Booker (Matthias Schoenaerts), and the under-used gay couple Joe (Marwan Kenzari) and Nicky (Luca Marinelli).
The complicated Booker was exiled for 100 years because of events in the first, when he tired of living forever. He sought an out, betraying them to Big Pharma, who wanted to monetize their power, but he thought they could help him.
In the only dramatic twist, he is asked back. Those fierce centuries-old loyalty bonds are hard to break, and the always appealing Belgian actor Schoenaerts works with the little he’s given for redemption.
They are joined by a new immortal, Nile (KiKi Laine), who was discovered in the original, as a Marine in Afghanistan. At first reluctant, she is now an integral warrior with the team.
Also on board is Chiwetel Ejiofor as ex-CIA agent Copley, who is their mortal tech expert. He is woefully underutilized here.
These adaptations are based on the graphic novel by Greg Rucka, who wrote the screenplay, and illustrated by Leandro Fernandez. Rucka is joined by screenwriter Sarah L. Walker.
The Old Guard was a huge streaming hit during the pandemic summer of 2020 and remains one of the most viewed movies on Netflix.
While dialogue is mostly by the book, as before, here there is more introspection, but that doesn’t mean the story is lucid.
After the first convoluted half-hour, where they are fighting in an arms dealer’s mansion in Croatia, some of the plot comes slowly into focus. They were saved from exposure the first-time around, but now a friend-turned-foe seeks to destroy them and a former friend returns, mad as hell.
Resurfacing is Quynh (Veronica Ngo), once Andy’s oldest and best friend 1,500 years ago, who was condemned to a watery grave in an iron maiden tomb during a witch hunt in the 16th century.
She wants revenge after being rescued 500 years later by the first-known immortal, Discord, menacingly played by Uma Thurman, who is not out to play nice.
Quynh is understandably upset after dying by drowning, then coming back to life again over five centuries. Andy carries a lot of guilt over what transpired and repeatedly looks lovingly at her former bestie.
Thurman, in ruthless villain mode, is saddled with an underdeveloped character with an axe to grind and lots o’ tools, tricks and toys at her disposal.
This intensifies the do-gooders’ mission. They are lured to an Indonesian nuclear power plant for an outnumbered battle near the core. Afterwards, the two alpha females will clash in a vicious throwdown.
Helping the good guys is Tuah (Henry Golding), a librarian tasked with keeping all the immortals’ records throughout the history of the world. He’s enlisted to explain the complex rules.
One key nugget he shares is that immortals cannot only lose their power, but they can transfer their power to someone who has lost theirs. These instances become logically confusing.
By finding out earlier that she could no longer heal supernaturally, Andy is wrestling with having an expiration date. A world of hurt and trouble is etched on her face.
Mesmerizing, the tall and muscular Theron has proven to be a formidable action hero, in Mad Max: Fury Road and the underrated Atomic Blonde.
The cast is strong this second go-round, that’s not the problem. While the first revealed some depth of character, here they seem one note, and usually mopey.
First director Gina Prince-Bythewood (The Woman King, The Secret Life of Bees) chose not to return, and her loss is major.
Following the first, this film is blood-soaked and brutally violent, with all sorts of wicked implements like swords and battle axes wielded. But this time, the combat set pieces are staged with little finesse by director Victoria Mahoney, less thrilling and more tedious.
The pacing is off overall, and there’s little reason to be invested in these escapades.
Most egregious of all, however, is a cliffhanger ending that assumes this film will have a sequel. Is there a cohesive direction to go, and more importantly, do we care what happens next? This time, the story is a letdown and the film ultimately forgettable.
The film premiered on Netflix on July 2, is rated R for graphic violence and some language, and is 1 hour, 46 minutes long.
