SILENT FRIEND – Review by Cate Marquis
A centuries-old, towering ginkgo tree in the botanical garden near the campus of a German university is the common thread connecting the stories of three scientists at that university, in Hungarian director Ildiko Enyedi’s intriguing, visually-thrilling drama Silent Friend. Painterly photography of the lovely, tree-filled campus, supplemented by striking, artistic micro nature photography, gives this drama spanning three time periods a dreamy, ethereal quality. The film tells the stories of three scientists on the same campus, in different time periods but all doing experiments to advance the understanding of plants and communication between plant and humans.
The film starts with Chinese neurologist Dr. Tony Wong (Tony Leung Chiu-wai), who finds himself stranded, nearly alone, on the German university campus when the Covid 19 pandemic hits. Unable to continue his human brain research, he turns to using his neurological equipment on the giant ginkgo tree nearby, attempting to explore the possibility of communication between plant and humans, with research guidance, via Zoom, from an academic who specializes in plant communications, Dr. Alice Sauvage (Lea Seydoux).
The second story is set in 1908 and presented in black-and-white footage, centered on a brilliant young woman botanist, Grete (Luna Wedler), who is seeking admission to be the university’s first female student and who perseveres in the face of considerable discrimination.
The third tale is set in 1972, with farm-raised university student Hannes (Enzo Brumm) making some startling discoveries about plant-human communication while caring for his botanist girlfriend Gundula’s (Marlene Burow) on-going plant-communication experiment, while she is away on a camping trip.
The stories alternate, abd they are mostly connected by the campus, studies of plants’ ability to communicate, and that big beautiful tree, but all the stories are supported by superb, gorgeous nature cinematography, with breathtaking, beautiful scientific images of plants, from cellular to close-ups of structures, in either deeply-textured black-and-white images or vibrantly colorful ones.
The film is enjoyable enough for its visual imagery alone, but also tells an intriguing, almost spiritual story of attempted communication between human and plant.
