HEAD TO HEAD (TIFF 2026) – Review by Beth Accomando

0 Flares 0 Flares ×

Iranian cinema has often been marked by a self-reflexive lens. Abbas Kiarostami, Jafar Panahi and Mohsen Makhmalbaf have displayed mastery at employing the approach to create multi-layered and slyly political films. The self-reflexive approach feels provocatively bold and experimental but also deeply personal, especially in a country where multiple directors have been arrested, placed under house arrest or banned from filmmaking.

The TIFF selection Head to Head continues in this tradition as it examines the cultural oppression women feel in Iran.

Filmmaker Ghasideh Golmakani was born in Tehran but moved to Paris where she completed her PhD with a dissertation entitled The Struggle of Iranian Women Filmmakers Before and After the Revolution. And she did not want to examine that struggle from afar. She returned to Iran where she made shorts, documentaries and behind the scenes films for other directors. Her short fiction films focus often focus on violence experienced by women in Iran.

Head to Head marks her narrative feature debut although it feels very much like a documentary in how it addresses women’s issues.

Golmakani’s alter ego in the film is Bahar (Mehrnoosh Satari), a woman director whose was imprisoned for refusing to wear a head scarf and has since been banned from making films. But she is not backing down from either her political beliefs or her politics. She has decided to make a new film in which the cast consists entirely of male actors required to wear headscarves and skirts, on camera and off. She does not intend this as a gender swap. They are simply men forced to wear the same garments women must wear even if it is hot or uncomfortable. She also demands that they move like women and refrain from anything that might be perceived as provocative.

The men react in varying degrees. One silently obeys while another, Sina (Saeed Naderi), rebels at every turn calling it stupid and removing his head scarf any chance he gets. Bahir has scenes she asks them to perform. But she also has a second cameraperson, Ebi (Ebrahim Azizi), surreptitiously shooting the cast when they are “off camera” and having dinner or arguing with the director. And it’s this footage that is designed to be the real film.

Bahar wants the men to experience having to wear a head scarf all the time, or to refrain from even the slightest physical movement that could be read as provocative. She wants them to push back against her demands but to also empathize with what women are put through and to understand that their struggle is part of a bigger universal struggle. She wants them to see and understand the inequities from a firsthand perspective.

She hopes the fact that she is making the film illegally and risking everything, will somehow impress upon the men how important this issue is to her. Initially the men see the head scarf as just a prop in the film, a gimmick Bahar is using to make a point. But as the film progresses, we see that it is a tool of the government to exact control over women and to deny choice and free will. Bahar uses the head scarf as a kind of symbol of how Iranian people have just come to accept the repression of its government.

The men are subjected to not only having to always wear a head scarf, but also to not having access to their cell phones, being restricted in their movements and kept locked up in a compound. They complain about lack of freedom and feeling imprisoned and with no sense of privacy. All of that is what Bahar wants them to feel and wants them to understand. She wants them to acknowledge that men are making the laws that women are forced to obey, and she wants men to join her in her fight.

But Bahar is also frustrated and angered by male Iranian directors that she feels take up the female cause without actually having insight into the issues.

The film is sometimes a little too on point with its message, but Golmakani is so fiercely passionate and often slyly funny that we can forgive her for sometimes being blunt in driving home a point. Her anger is beautifully captured in Satari’s performance as Bahar. She conveys a ferocious anger and frustration that at one point finally explodes in a primal scream.

Head to Head, like many of Iran’s best films, has an absurd sometimes surreal quality because people like Bahar feel caught in an insane world where what’s considered normal is anything but. It is a film that struggles with what the role of an artist can be in fighting that insanity. Golmakani’s first narrative feature is a smart, sly, tragic, provocative work that can’t be ignored.

0 Flares Twitter 0 Facebook 0 0 Flares ×

Beth Accomando

Beth Accomando is host of KPBS Cinema Junkie Podcast and author of the blog Cinema Junkie. She also programs film series and events as part of Film Geeks SD at venues such as Museum of Photographic Arts and Digital Gym Cinema. She loves horror, zombies, kaiju and film noir.