A REAL PAIN, Holocaust Tourism & Gaza – Essay by Yael Friedman

0 Flares 0 Flares ×

Among the disappointments in this year’s Oscars was that the original screenplay award didn’t go to A Real Pain, which was head and shoulders above the rest in its category. I blame the trailer industry for my initial resistance to seeing A Real Pain. It spun the movie into the kind of “quirky” buddy + Holocaust movie I would avoid at all costs – a sizzle reel of punchlines and poignancy. I dreaded seeing it and also knew I had to, at least as homework. Friends told me it was great and I just assumed they were wrong. But it was wonderful.

Somehow the backdrop of a Jewish roots/Holocaust tour of Poland didn’t even feel contrived or “ugh not again” (“Never Again” pun not intended). I’m not bemoaning the “Holocaust movie” – there will always be innumerable ways to portray the Holocaust’s seemingly infinite facets and insights into history and human nature. I’m also not criticizing Holocaust tours – there is really no substitute for having a concrete connection with history, whether one’s own or that of others. Years ago, I finally visited Ireland, after a near lifetime of being engrossed in its history. I knew about the Famine, I’d read so much about the North and the Troubles, and yet it wasn’t until I actually walked through empty countrysides with overgrown Famine Cottages, and hiked the small hills of West Belfast amid the murals and “peace line” barriers, that I could internalize any of it. And when I finally visited Auschwitz — reluctantly, because I felt like really what was there left for me to uncover, in history or within myself — it affected me so viscerally; I realized there is no substitute for that, no text or even survivor testimony that can so quickly plunge you into what that place was.

Still from A REAL PAIN

A Real Pain utilizes this familiar tourist trip as a convincing canvas. Nailing down the charmingly Bohemian Benji (Kieran Culkin) by booking a conventional tour by the more conventional cousin David (Jesse Eisenberg), made sense. It was a perfect vehicle for allowing their dynamics, personalities, the themes of memory and trauma tourism, to unfold. The exposition in this screenplay was a master class, even if both actors played versions of themselves, or because of it. Use what you have, it’s a neat sleight of hand to turn a character you think you know into one entirely invented. As fun as Benji was, as delightful to the rest of the tour group, as envious as the more straitlaced and neurotic David got (as you could tell he has all his life) the tragedy of Benji’s character pierced deeply. He endeared and broke and enraged you in equal measure. We never really find out why Benji has been cast adrift in life, and we don’t need to. We meet him where he is and worry for what is next. Just enough is given to make it real and utterly palpable. And the flatter more two-dimensional secondary characters seemed intended to be that way, drawn to serve as foils. They form discrete parts of that trip as much as the sites themselves.

Still from A REAL PAIN

Eisenberg’s deployment of Benji as the open skeptic during the solemn (and standard) Holocaust sightseeing was also brilliant. Very few would dispense with politeness to question the narration of a young and earnest Oxbridge tour guide who has devoted his life to studying genocide. And that you mostly identify with David (or at least I did) and think well of course Holocaust tourism is fraught, but I’d discuss it later and not make everyone feel terrible, makes Benji’s utility as an unnerving truth-teller even more valuable. Though most of the rest of the characters on the tour probably didn’t agree at all and didn’t necessarily contemplate that anything was amiss in such a journey, this was precisely what they paid for. They wanted to learn but equally to have all of their notions about the meaning of this past validated.

At this point in history, tours that map out the Holocaust are well worn – they are extremely important but they are also many of the things Benji accuses them of. There is something perverse in returning to your luxury hotel after spending the day in a death camp, just as there is in narrating history in the literal graveyard of one of history’s worst atrocities; of asking yet another group to lay stones at graves as Jewish tradition provides. You wonder, did they have to clear the stones from the previous group?

Still from A REAL PAIN

These tours and the weight of the Holocaust are also often intended, on some level, to underscore “Never Again,” for anyone. The camps and the graveyards and the ghost towns of once thriving communities are meant to instill a deep resonance with present atrocities. And yet, it doesn’t always seem like the generalities extend beyond the particulars, the quotidian beyond the exceptional. No matter what. History does not extend into the present. One could argue that the Holocaust is not meant to serve as education, but is it possible to peer into the worst of the past while not looking at it from the present? It doesn’t have to be analogous — it shouldn’t be analogous; history is too contingent for that. But “Never Again” is deeply inscribed into Holocaust education and remembrance and one would hope that one cannot look in horror at it without thinking about the present.

Still from A REAL PAIN

But in what way should the Holocaust be absorbed? In her popular essays for The Atlantic and elsewhere, the writer and scholar Dara Horn spends time on how this fascination and reverence for the Holocaust undermines conscientiousness about the present. I partially agree but mostly vehemently disagree and even think her main points are dangerous. For Horn, this focus on the Holocaust and Holocaust education mainly affects current ideas and evaluations of Jews — that people may only know about the 20th Century suffering of the Jews, and about Hitler, but don’t have sufficient understanding and appreciation for Jews as a people today or of historical antisemitism. Lessons about the Holocaust also absolve people of their present sins by having them engage with a past they had no role in, and often with a people they may never meet (most Holocaust education is taught by non-Jews to non-Jews in places with no Jews). It is easier to teach about the Holocaust than say, American civil rights, or American anything. Since Americans weren’t complicit in the Holocaust, and it didn’t happen here, it does not compel any actual critical thinking about the world as it is now. It’s a safe subject that can enable feelings of righteousness that on would have done the right thing.

This all resonates but Horn’s next logical leap does not. Her focus does not turn to the bigger problem of ignorance about the past and all that is not taught. She only seems concerned with how this fetishization of the Holocaust affects antisemitism. I once went to a Holocaust Memorial Day event at the synagogue on my street in Greenpoint (in a building on Noble St. you’d easily miss but which is extraordinary inside — the oldest operating shul in Brooklyn). The evening focused on the work of artists whose subjects were some of the last remaining survivors. An audience member commented that this was all valuable but everyone in that room already knew this story; outside those four walls, a very low percentage of Americans even know the Holocaust occurred. My reaction to that was people don’t know a lot about a lot. It’s not just the Holocaust, and in my bones (and well, backed by hard data) despite the rise in antisemitism, I still think Jews as a group have been thriving in America. In my mind I wondered how many Americans also don’t know about redlining or Reconstruction.

Greenpoint Shul. Brooklyn, New York

Horn has pointed out that at the National Museum of African American History and Culture in Washington, D.C., there is no exhibition highlighting similar plights of other peoples (as in Holocaust museums) and that “That approach would be an insult to Black history, ignoring Black people’s current experiences while turning their past oppression into nothing but a symbol for something else.” Yet, the Holocaust did not happen here, and except for Jewish immigration to the US, has not formed the Jewish experience in the way slavery and systemic racism have shaped the American experience (not just African American, our society as a whole). She would probably agree that the reason so many Holocaust museums arose before one devoted to the legacy of slavery and African American history, is because Holocaust museums do not compel visitors to examine their own lives and the world today. Yet she does not think this is the main problem, for her the burning issue is how it affects antisemitism now.

Yet in her essay about the cynical Congressional December 2023 hearings about college campus antisemitism, Horn seems to have abdicated her own impassioned plea that Jewish suffering not be fetishized to serve ulterior motives; that fixation on it not undermine wrestling with the real problems of the present. The essay includes an inventory of acts of antisemitism by the left without any kind of accounting of the dangerous radicalization of the right and by the right. The Tree of Life Shooting in Pittsburgh was perpetrated by a man who found refuge in the worst online forums and radio programs that fed him prepackaged paranoia about the Great Replacement theory and other new spins on old prejudices meant to undermine humanistic progressive values and “owning the libs.”

Tree of Life Shootings, Pittsburgh

Horn is at the forefront of a frenzy that implores us to be obsessed with antisemitism on the left, begging us to see that antisemitism is rearing its thousands’ year-old head and we overlook it because it does not meet the crisis marks of the Holocaust. Again, she overlooks the conditions of the present to make analogies with the past, despite asking us not to when it comes to “learning from the Holocaust.” It’s been such a slide to the right for so many in this way, and it’s terrifying.

Especially with what is still happening in Gaza, it seems utterly perverse and irrelevant to focus on the legacy of the Holocaust as it pertains just to Jews. And to focus on it to the extent that you are enabling outright fascism (as in the recent detention of Mahmoud Khalil) is so obscene and yet so unsurprising by now that even seeing the Anti-Defamation League championing it only feels like a new but predictable low.

Last September, my partner and I finally visited Vilnius, Lithuania, where my mother is from, and where my grandparents lived incredibly rich lives before the war. They both lost their entire families, as did most Lithuanian Jews. Of the 155,000 Jews in Lithuania before the war, about 8,000 survived. Vilna (the Jewish name for Vilnius) was a city of mythic proportions, the “Jerusalem of the North” – a spiritual and intellectual center with a wide range of religiosity, assimilation, class, occupation – my paternal great grandmother was a trained doctor, and my maternal great grandmother was kosher but lived with her son’s family who was not. My grandmother, Nina, became a partisan during the war, landing missions behind enemy lines, and my grandfather, Joseph, fought in the Red Army. They were both in high school when the Germans entered the city and their entire worlds evaporated. You never know which part of these stories will haunt you the most. For me it was my grandmother telling me, almost as an aside, that one year before the war, when she was 16 years old, a schoolmate’s mother died. Nina would look at her and think, how is she able to go on, how is she walking around like nothing is wrong when her whole world has just been upended.

Vilnius/Vilna, Lithuania pre-WWII

For our visit, my mother recommended a guide who is popular with Jewish tourists visiting Lithuania, especially ones who might already know a fair bit. And she was incredible, as a guide and a person. Laima (not her real name) is not Jewish, and her family saved more than a dozen Jews during the war, which is as close to miraculous and heroic as anything I can think of. Laima’s energy and wealth of knowledge is nearly superhuman, and her passion and abhorrence for what happened to Lithuania’s Jews so clear and so fundamental to her need to redress the past. She is a woman on a mission. And in a country that has serious revisionist and apologist tendencies, this is not a dead issue.

And yet, burning in my mind was the present death and dying in Gaza, as I looked on these revived ghosts meant to give their testimony. I wondered whether the others on these tours also felt that or, I suspect more likely, focused on the rise in antisemitism, or maybe narrowly focused on the tragedy of what happened and how exceptional it was. In the way Horn thinks Holocaust education absolves American non-Jews, it seems to similarly absolve many Jews, keeping their focus on their own history of suffering. It is a real history, and antisemitism is very much alive, the old tropes that led to the Holocaust have not died. I have personally experienced the assumption that Jews leverage enormous wealth, power, and control, by folks who did not even think they were saying anything wrong. It still chills me. And yet, focusing only on that distracts us from the real fight on our hands, a fight on so many fronts. Worse than a distraction, the use of antisemitism by the right, is the worst legacy the Holocaust could possibly have.

In A Real Pain Eisenberg also made use of another reason many go on these tours – a connection with one’s own family history, a communion with the past that is supposed to give more meaning to the present. A certain tethering. The expectations are always outsized and sometimes they are met, but they are so unpredictable. Benji and David leave the group at the end to find the home in Lublin that their grandmother fled. When they finally arrive, and realize now what, they decide to mark the moment by laying stones at the threshold. But the past is also hard to summon with the neighbors looking on and eventually telling them to please remove the stones as the woman living inside might trip over them. The journey itself felt like an effort by David to bond with his elusive and troubled cousin, extend the roots of their family and one another. But they left each other as they met, perhaps changed but not towards one another, and you suspect for Benji, not towards anything at all.

Still from A REAL PAIN

Growing up, I’d heard so much about Vilna, and it might have become far too grand or at least stuck in a prelapsarian past. I remember visiting Vienna for the first time a few years ago, this former seat of imperial power and heady intellectual ferment of so many generations. The city I found was tiny and its past well past. It was charming but it didn’t square with my ideas about it. I had a similar experience with Vilna. Probably especially because the entire world that I had heard about was erased; I could kind of feel it and imagine it but not completely. The most visceral feeling I had there was actually from watching Lithuanians walking around and living in the old Jewish neighborhoods. Despite serving as the capital of Lithuania for centuries, Vilnius was never very ethnically Lithuanian – it was a very Polish and Jewish city. After the war that changed. Of course, young Lithuanians have nothing to do with the war, but since I was already in a city of ghosts, their faces were those of their grandparents and great grandparents, walking the streets of those they replaced. Visiting my mother’s old neighborhood and imagining her there did feel more personal but I think I wanted more (my grandparents returned to Vilna after the war where they found each other and got married; my mother was born in 1946 and they eventually left for Israel by way of Poland in 1956, fleeing the antisemitism of the Soviet Union).

We also visited a forest outside of the city where my grandmother, along with other partisans, hid in bunkers. Seeing those small underground hatches, you could feel the history as closely as one can. However, because the Soviets supported the partisans and every Lithuanian schoolchild had to visit these bunkers to understand Soviet glory, they are now almost completely overgrown and will soon disappear. Russia continues to give Lithuania no choice but to define itself in opposition to it and be constantly reminded of what Russian imperialism means. But for those of us whose history lies beneath their feet, it is still hard to watch and feel. Certain histories recede more quickly, depending on the gatekeepers.

 width=

Holocaust Legacy: Bunkers near Vilnius/Vilna

Visiting Vilna absolutely changed me but mostly in the way traveling does – your internal map — of the world, of history, of people — expands. But I think I mostly felt the direct experience of a post-Soviet country rather than my own family’s presence. And I wondered whether the young in Lithuania were mostly preoccupied with Ukraine or also had space to think about Gaza. I wish I had more time there to understand and speak to them. The danger at their own door is so urgent, I wouldn’t blame them if that was what filled their minds. But I could not fathom other Americans, or Israelis, visiting to trace their own histories, and learn of the destruction of their own people, while fascism continues its ugly ascent at home and thousands die in Gaza and not feel that as viscerally as anything else.

ABOUT YAEL FRIEDMAN

Yael Friedman is a journalist based in New York. She covers art and culture and their intersection with economics, politics, and history. She has written extensively about urban history and urban planning, particularly New York’s, analyzing its past and assessing its present and future. Her articles have appeared in Bloomberg CityLab, 1843, The Conversationalist, The Economist, The Daily Beast, Haaretz, Forward, Los Angeles Review of Books, and Urban Omnibus.

0 Flares Twitter 0 Facebook 0 0 Flares ×
explore: | | | | | | | | | | |